Book list
From Booklist, Copyright © American Library Association. Used with permission.

Lonely and bright, an only child brought up by parents less flush than her peers' parents, Rebecca turns to new-girl Alex like a flower to the sun. In ever-vernal 1960s Pasadena, opposites Rebecca and Alex become fast and fierce friends, stuck together like two ends of a battery. Their charge begins to weaken, however, when Alex's interest in theater summons her away to camp, all but fizzles in college when Rebecca would rather study biology than attempt to understand one of Alex's obscure performances, and is extinguished to near death when one dark moment leads Rebecca to make a fateful decision. Her best friend spurned and her dream of following medicine dashed in one fell swoop, Rebecca escapes restrictive southern California and the mother whose only wish for her is to marry well and starts anew. Before long, though, she and Alex reconnect, and the true nature and madness of their friendship unfurls. An impressive psychological drama, Sloss' first novel aptly brings to the fore the social issues that uniquely challenge her heroine.--Bostrom, Annie Copyright 2010 Booklist

Library Journal
(c) Copyright Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Introverted, bookish Rebecca and flamboyant, dynamic Alexandra meet at age 14 and instantly become best friends. We follow them from high school through college and into marriage and motherhood, with social change from the late 1950s through the early 1970s as backdrop. Told from Rebecca's point of view, their volatile friendship is the almost exclusive focus of the narrative, as the two young women find their career ambitions constricted by social norms and expectations and settle for unsatisfying or unhappy marriages. The narrative structure is at times frustrating, as Rebecca reveals information very selectively. In the end, however, one discovers that this is by design, and earlier puzzles (including the true meaning of the novel's title) are made clear by the revelations of the book's final pages. More troubling is the character of Alexandra, who is so insufferably self-centered and overbearing that it's difficult to buy into Rebecca's attachment to her. VERDICT If Rebecca's relationship with the difficult Alexandra can be accepted, book clubs may find much to discuss regarding women's friendships, social class, and changes in women's options as a result of the feminist movement. [See Prepub Alert, 8/9/12].-Christine DeZelar-Tiedman, Univ. of Minnesota Libs., Minneapolis (c) Copyright 2013. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.

Kirkus
Copyright © Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

What if the greatest love of your life were your best friend? Since childhood, Rebecca Madden's and Alexandra "Alex" Carrington's lives have twined and twisted around each other's, and the stories of their lives weave into a single autobiography. Told from Rebecca's perspective, the tale fairly seeps with desire for the missing half, just as Rebecca yearns for Alex whenever she leaves. And she does leave. Despite her patrician mother's reservations, Alex abandons Rebecca the summer before college to attend a theater arts camp. Letters come less and less often, leaving Rebecca to mourn until her suddenly very chic friend arrives to whisk both of them off to college. Alex promptly disappears again, keeping late hours and drifting into a glamorous world of drama, men, drinks and cigarettes. Although Rebecca tries to keep her moral compass as straight as her parents shaped it, she, too, has secrets. Dreaming of a career in medicine, Rebecca sneaks out of the dorm early and comes home late, hiding her studies from everyone who would point out the near impossibility of a woman becoming a doctor then. Yet again and again, Rebecca and Alex come together, drawn to each other like magnets. An early-summer wedding party brings catastrophe, however, when Rebecca finds Alex's date, the enigmatic, charismatic Bertrand Lowell, impossible to ignore. The evening sets in motion a betrayal deep enough to send Rebecca and Alex careening wildly off their courses. Sloss' debut novel sweeps across the tumultuous events of the late 1950s through the 1980s, navigating the characters through the fear of race riots, the loss of friends to the conflict in Vietnam and the battle for women's rights. Captivating, engrossing, surprising--the autobiography of Rebecca and Alex celebrates the terrible struggle to find one's identity as it elegiacally rues the necessary losses.]] Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.

Publishers Weekly
(c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved

A smooth first-person narrative about two best friends who come of age in 1960s Pasadena marks Sloss's layered debut novel. Alex is beautiful, theatrical, and comes from wealth. Introspective, secretive, and brainy narrator Rebecca lives "house-poor" with her earnest father and beautiful, thrifty mother, who wants her daughter to have what she lost during the Depression. Once inseparable, the friends strike out on different paths at their college and a total break occurs after junior year. The incident, involving lies, alcohol, and some bad judgment, changes Rebecca's relationship with her parents as well. Stifled by early '60s sexism, she grows passive, marrying Paul, a genial, patrician New York lawyer. Despite achieving her mother's goals, her marriage is a sham and her small life revolves around her two sons and the letters she writes to Alex but never sends. Home for her mother's funeral, Rebecca reconnects with her one-time best friend, but she begins to see the insignificance of her life. Here the narrative accelerates as it builds toward the chaotic denouement. The story's hopeful end is tempered with the realization that, had the central characters been born a generation later, maybe their lives would have been better. Agent: Claudia Ballard, WME Entertainment. (Feb.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved.